Mom got this out of one her first cookbooks that daddy bought her right after they got married. Better Homes and Gardens Dessert Cookbook. I have the recipe book and will cherish it always. She used to make it for him and for his dad, and grandpa still talked about mom’s pie up until the day he passed away. Grandpa passed away 2 days after Christmas and I remember on Christmas day that year, he asked me if my mom was making some of her good pies. Sweet memories…
Chocolate Pie
1 c sugar
3 heaping T cornstarch
3 level T of Hershey’s cocoa powder
1/4 t salt
12 oz milnot plus enough water to make 2 cups (or just 2 cups of milk)
3 beaten egg yolks (reserve whites for your meringue if making one)
2 T butter
1 t vanilla
Combine sugar, cornstarch, salt and cocoa in medium sauce pan, add milnot and eggs and mix well. Put on medium heat and bring up to heat, stirring CONSTANTLY making sure to scrape the sides and bottom of the pan CONTINUALLY. ( I use a whisk). It will thicken as you cook and stir, don’t rush it or it WILL SCORCH!When about half way thicken, remove add butter and vanilla and place back on fire and finish cooking. Let cool and pour into a prebaked pie crust. (see recipe for mom’s pie crust). Mom always served it in a plain pastry crust, but last year due to time restraints, I poured it into a store bought small graham cracker crust topped with Cool Whip and shaved a Hersey bar over the cool whip. It was beautiful and delicious.